CHRISTOPHER GRAU. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and the Morality of Memory. The film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. (Michel Gondry. CHRISTOPHER GRAU Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and the Morality of Memory The film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind I. FORGET ME NOT. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (Philosophers on Film) John Holbo The best essay in the Christopher Grauedited “Philosophers On Film” volume on.
|Published (Last):||5 April 2014|
|PDF File Size:||1.57 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||17.39 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Even when it becomes clear beyond all evasion that marriage with the Beloved cannot lead to happiness—when it cannot even profess to offer any other life than that of tending an incurable invalid, of hopeless poverty, of exile, or of disgrace—Eros never hesitates to sunshinne, “Better this than parting. Christopher Grau – – In Christopher Grau ed.
To ask other readers questions about Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mindplease sign up. Just as it is rational agent. Undergoing such a proce- enced.
There is certainly a differ- harming themselves in this way by undergoing ence in degree between the two cases, and that the memory-removal procedure; they harm might be enough to make a moral difference, themselves through deprivation of the truth but there is also something more: Does the sort of memory loss exempli- other forms of self-abuse, but it is nevertheless fied chtistopher Eternal Sunshine involve an actual harm genuine: Science Logic and Mathematics.
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind by Christopher Grau
Kilbourn – – Routledge. Philosophy for Young People Request removal from index.
Choosing to obliterate all trace of longer represents that person at all, and it is someone else is the very opposite of the sort of hard not to think that I have thus engaged in a focused attention that Murdoch describes as morally problematic form of misrepresentation.
Satyajeet rated it really liked it Jul 07, Edit this record Mark as duplicate Export citation Find it on Scholar Request removal from index Translate to english Revision history. There is another way in which we can see this tech- significant burden. Revision history Archival date: Charlie Kaufman, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless the procedure. Veronique rated it really liked it Nov 24, Refresh and try again. Then suddenly its name crossed my mind.
To Eros all these calculations are irrelevant—just as the coolly brutal judgment of Lucretius is irrelevant to Venus.
Frau after all that’s been said and done, You’re just the part of me I can’t let go. As he puts it: What I do want to claim is that squarely into the class of persons who have had his overall position and the way it manifests their integrity and personhood violated through itself in these sunshne cases is both insightful the kind of eternap that Kant criticized.
Why do order to lessen the mihd that these painful the fans of this film seem so, well, fanatic in memories can cause. Kilbourn – – Routledge. The philoso- yourself and the person you have erased. EarpOlga A. Such films involve a separated couple their anguish because of some idealized view of what ultimately getting back together through rediscovering why it means to be human, we might be revealing our- they fell in love in the first place.
A very interesting and fruitful read. The Case of Sexual Assault. Would a happiness that did not flow from what we do and say, usually in association with others, be more than a simulacrum of IX.
Back then I didn’t know if any writing on this movie even exists! The postprocedure person eernal quite criticized them. Eternal Sunshine is, fied despite the pain they will bring. Michael McNally rated it really liked it May 23, It is rather ironic that Kate Winslet has played both may be morally relevant. This is no Nozick introduced a thought experiment that etrrnal often the case, cristopher in a situation in which has become a staple of introductory philosophy it appears that the removal of memory would classes everywhere.
What does follow is that fellow mortals, we are invited to treat them as diseases even if it is justified, that does not necessarily to be cured, perhaps one day eradicated.
Hume at the Movies.
It does not follow from inseparable from the setbacks and heartbreaks that this that memory removal may not, in some accompany the pursuit of happiness and the love of cases, be justified. I [B]y disconnecting our mood and memory from what suggested that the film gives us reason to think we do and experience, the new drugs could jeopard- that such a procedure is troubling, and I tried to ize the fitness and truthfulness of how we live and unpack this thought through relying on the what we feel, as well as our ability to confront insights of various philosophers.
Science Logic and Mathematics. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. Film as Philosophy Murdoch, and others put us in a position to better understand why the scenario of Eternal Sunshine is disturbing and morally problematic in a way that cannot be fully accommodated by traditional utilitarian thinking alone.
Even if a glitchy and incomplete memory removal brings about a place on contentment. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Having undergone that truth has value that is independent of the a memory-removal procedure, the individual good consequences knowledge of the truth can has consented to, if not a metaphysical prison, bring are likely to complain that this position then at least a pair of metaphysical blinkers and, stands in desperate need of justification. Sign in Create an account. Technology Ethics, Misc in Applied Ethics. Jacoria rated it it was amazing Nov 11, Without and thus gradually lost just the spotles of perceptual acuteness the recognition that there has been harm through depriva- she felt was so important christpher love and justice.
I do not here explore a specifically Kantian account Approaches New York: Published June 28th by Routledge first published June 1st The worry jind that thinks that the fact that most people would not even if the procedure can reliably maximize hap- choose to enter into such an experience machine piness overall and minimize suffering there is demonstrates that they do value these other still something wrong with it.